humancode.us

Open Source Software is the Pastime of the Rich

September 18, 2024

Open Source Software in a world of capitalism can only exist as a pastime for the already-rich. Only companies extracting profit from something else can afford to maintain OSS. Only individuals paid for something else can contribute significant time to OSS projects in their spare time.

It’s a precarious thing to profit directly from maintaining OSS and selling it as a service, precisely because someone else can copy and repackage your work for less money—which is entirely within the spirit of OSS—and undercut your business model. A business truly in the spirit of GPL would celebrate such a copy; but a business that must profit from their work on OSS would see it as theft of their livelihood.

In other words, insistence on “pure altruism” as the basis of open-source software is essentially a shorthand for excluding those who are not already wealthy. It’s elitist.